As you know, there are lots of things that can mess with your workout. You could not get enough sleep the night before, you could exercise on an empty stomach, or you could simply do the moves wrong, to name a few. Well, here's the latest fitness faux pas to add to your list: taking a vitamin D2 supplement. According to a new study from Appalachian State University, published in the journal Nutrients, doing so could damage your muscles bigtime. 

For the study, researchers divided 28 NASCAR pit crew athletes into two groups. Half of the group took a vitamin D2 supplement for six weeks, and the other half took a placebo pill. After six weeks, the scientists had both groups do 90 minutes of intense exercise, and then took their blood samples (they’d also taken samples at the start of the study, before the participants took the supplements at all). The results? After the exercise session, participants who’d taken the vitamin D2 supplement had higher muscle damage than those who didn’t take the pill. And even though the participants in the study were all male, lead study author David Neiman, PhD, says that the results can apply to females as well. 

The reason actually may have to do with another vitamin entirely: vitamin D3. See, when the participants were given the vitamin D2, their levels of vitamin D3 in their bloodstream went down—and it’s that specific drop that researchers believe could be the reason that their muscles saw more damage overall. This is especially important to note, as many people believe that vitamin D2 and D3 are interchangeable—but Neiman emphasizes that they definitely are not.

The muscle moral: Skip the vitamin D2 supplements altogether, Neiman suggests. Instead, head out into the sun (yes, even in winter—just bundle up!) to score natural vitamin D from the great outdoors. Just be careful to follow these 6 new sun protection secrets!

Headshot of Annie Daly
Annie Daly

Annie Daly is a New York City-based freelance writer, editor, and author who specializes in wellness, travel, and culture. She is the author of Destination Wellness (2021), and co-author of Island Wisdom (2022). A former editor at SELF, Cosmopolitan, BuzzFeed Travel, Yahoo Travel, and Good Housekeeping, she has also written for a variety of publications, including Condé Nast Traveler, Vogue, Travel + Leisure, Marie Claire, InStyle, and AFAR, among others. To follow her work, find her on IG @anniemdaly and subscribe to her Substack, Destination Wellness.